X, Q, J and Z can be a shortcut or a dead end. The difference is whether the target shares them.
Rare letters are a gamble. A word with an x, a q, a j or a z can be the shortest bridge in a ladder, and it can also be a one-way door. The deciding question is not whether the letter is rare. It is whether the target also needs it.
If the target contains the same rare letter, a rare-letter pivot is often excellent, because both sides of the ladder want that letter and the swap that introduces it is unlikely to be wasted. If the target does not contain it, the move is usually a detour, and the letter has to be removed again later, which costs another rung.
There is a second, subtler point. Rare-letter words often have small neighbourhoods. A word with a q might have three legal neighbours and all of them are obscure. That lowers the odds of recovering from a bad guess. Players who love rare letters tend to have short, brilliant runs and long, hopeless ones, and the average is worse than it looks.
The practical rule: count the rare letters on the board before the first move. If the target shares one, treat rare-letter words as candidates. If it does not, avoid the tempting one.
This is a rule that has to be learned on the board rather than in a paragraph. Try today's puzzle and check the letters first, before looking at any candidate word. Click here if the current puzzle has no rare letters at all, and use that day to build the contrast, because the rule only becomes visible when the two cases are compared.
One extra signal is how the rare letter behaves when it changes. If changing it produces a common word, the move is probably fine, because there is a way back. If changing it produces nothing, the rare letter is load-bearing and the word is a one-way door. That check takes seconds and it catches most of the bad bets.